               Public Access to Court Electronic Records

                       Docket Report Output Menu

          Docket for case  1:87cv02028  consists of  17  pages.

  Case was last updated on:  12/15/97 .  Report was generated on:  12/15/97 .

X---------------------------------------------------------------------------X
PACER session date: Sunday May 24, 1998 05:00:59 PM EDT                      
Case docket was last updated on: 12/15/97.                                   
                                                                             
                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 1                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
                                                            MAGr&r TYPE I    
                                                            JURY             
                       U.S. District Court                                   
             USDC District of Columbia (Washington)                          
                                                                             
               CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 87-CV-2028                           
                                                                             
GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                    Filed: 07/22/87  
Assigned to: Judge Thomas P. Jackson                                         
             Referred to: Mag. Judge Patrick J. Attridge                     
Demand: $0,000                               Nature of Suit:  895            
Lead Docket: None                            Jurisdiction: US Defendant      

Lead Docket: None                            Jurisdiction: US Defendant      
Dkt# in other court: None                                                    
                                                                             
Cause: 05:552 Freedom of Information Act                                     
Case type: 1. civil 2. null                                                  
                                                                             
                                                                             
PAUL GOLDSTEIN                    Bernard Fensterwald, III                   
     plaintiff                     [term  10/18/90]                          
                                  (703) 734-0500                             
                                  Suite 307                                  
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  FENSTERWALD & ALCORN                       
                                  1952 Gallows Road                          
                                  Vienna, VA 22182                           
                                                                             
                                  PAUL GOLDSTEIN                             
                                  [COR LD NTC] [PRO SE]                      
                                  115 Nottoway Street                        
                                  Leesburg, VA 22075                         
                                                                             



                                                                             
                                                                             
   v.                                                                        
                                                                             
                                                                             
OFFICE OF THE INDEPENDENT         Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
COUNSEL                           (202) 514-3449                             
     defendant                    [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (202) 514-3178                             
                                  Room 1062                                  
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (202) 514-4960                             
                                  Room 1072                                  
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE                 
                                  Civil Division                             
                                  901 E Street, NW                           
                                  Washington, DC 20004                       

                                  Washington, DC 20004                       
                                                                             
                                                                             
                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 2                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (202) 633-4770                             
                                  Room 3501                                  
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE                 
                                  Office of Information & Privacy            
                                  950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW                
                                  Washington, DC 20530-0001                  
                                                                             
                                  Guy Miller Struve                          
                                  (212) 450-4192                             

                                  (212) 450-4192                             
                                  Suite 3030                                 
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  DAVIS POLK & WARDWELL                      
                                  450 Lexington Avenue                       
                                  New York, NY 10017                         
                                                                             
                                                                             
FEDERAL BUREAU OF                 Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
INVESTIGATION                     (See above)                                
     defendant                    [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Patricia Arzuaga                           
                                  514-2395                                   
                                  907                                        

                                  907                                        
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE                 
                                  Civil Division                             
                                  901 E Street, NW                           
                                  Washington, DC 20004                       
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Karen Kathleen Richardson                  
                                  (202) 514-3374                             
                                  Suite 1032 POB 883                         
                                  [COR LD NTC gvt]                           
                                  U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE                 
                                  901 E Street, NW                           
                                  Washington, DC 20530                       
                                                                             
                                                                             

                                                                             
NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL         Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
     defendant                    (See above)                                
                                                                             
                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 3                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
                                  [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          

                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             
CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY       Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
     defendant                    (See above)                                
                                  [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             

                                                                             
                                                                             
BUREAU OF ALCOHOL, TOBACCO &      Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
FIREARMS                          (See above)                                
     defendant                    [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             
DOE                               Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
     defendant                    (See above)                                

     defendant                    (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                                                             
                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 4                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             

FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT      Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
AGENCY                            (See above)                                
     defendant                    [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             
DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY       Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
     defendant                    (See above)                                
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               

                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             
THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT      Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
OF THE ARMY                       (See above)                                
     defendant                    [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          

                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             
                                                                             
                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 5                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY            Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
     defendant                    (See above)                                
                                  [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                

                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE       Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
     defendant                    (See above)                                
                                  [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                   [term  05/21/91]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             

                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                                                             
NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY          Vincent Morgan Garvey                      
     defendant                    (See above)                                
                                  [COR]                                      
                                  Elizabeth Ann Pugh                         
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                  Marcia Kay Sowles                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               
                                                                             
                                  Alan L. Ferber                             
                                   [term  02/21/90]                          
                                  (See above)                                
                                  [COR LD NTC]                               

                                                                             
                                                                             
                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 6                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
7/22/87  1       COMPLAINT filed, exhibits (12), summons issued (yep)        
                 [Entry date 07/23/87]                                       
                                                                             
7/31/87  2       PETITION by PAUL GOLDSTEIN for preliminary injunction,      
                 and for expedited treatment; exhibits (2), declaration      
                 (1). (yep) [Entry date 08/04/87]                            
                                                                             
8/12/87  3       RESPONSE  by defendant in opposition to plaintiff's         
                 petition for a preliminary injunction and for expedited     
                 treatment, exhibits (3). (yep) [Entry date 08/13/87]        
                                                                             
8/12/87  4       MOTION by defendant OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL to dismiss the     
                 complaint as to OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, or in the             

                 complaint as to OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, or in the             
                 alternative, for summary judgment, and opposition to        
                 petition for preliminary injunction and expedited treatment;
                  affidavit (1), exhibits (2). (yep) [Entry date 08/13/87]   
                                                                             
8/20/87  5       ANSWER for defendants DEPT. AIR FORCE, DON, ARMY, DIA, FEMA,
                 DOE, BATF, NATL. SEC. AGENCY, CIA, NATL. SEC. COUNCIL, FBI, 
                 and OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, by counsel (yep)                  
                 [Entry date 08/21/87] [Edit date 09/29/87]                  
                                                                             
8/25/87  6       REPLY  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEINto defendant's opposition 
                 to petition for preliminary injunction [2-1], and expedited 
                 treatment [2-2] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN; attachments. (yep)       
                 [Entry date 08/26/87]                                       
                                                                             
8/25/87  7       REPLY  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to defendant OFFICE OF   
                 INDEPENDENT COUNSEL'S motion to dismiss the complaint as to 
                 OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL [4-1], and motion for summary judgment 
                 [4-2] by OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, and opposition to            
                 plaintiff's petition for preliminary injunction and         
                 expedited treatment; attachment (1). (yep)                  

                 expedited treatment; attachment (1). (yep)                  
                 [Entry date 08/26/87]                                       
                                                                             
9/1/87   8       REPLY  by defendant OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL to responseby      
                 plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN in opposition to motion for        
                 summary judgment [4-2], or in the alternative, to dismiss   
                 the complaint as to OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL [4-1] by OFFICE OF 
                 INDEP.CNSL (yep) [Entry date 09/02/87]                      
                                                                             
9/2/87   --      STATUS HEARING before Judge Thomas P. Jackson : heard and   
                 denied petition for preliminary injunction [2-1] by PAUL    
                 GOLDSTEIN, scheduled further  status hearing for 10:00      
                 10/2/87 reporter M. Colchico (yep) [Entry date 09/04/87]    
                                                                             
9/2/87   9       ORDER by Judge Thomas P. Jackson denying plaintiff's        
                 petition for preliminary injunction [2-1], and scheduling a 
                 INDEPENDENT COUNSEL'S motion to dismiss the complaint as to 
                 OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL [4-1], and motion for summary judgment 
                 [4-2] by OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, and opposition to            
                 plaintiff's petition for preliminary injunction and         
                 expedited treatment; attachment (1). (yep)                  

                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 7                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
9/10/87  10      NOTICE OF INTERLOCUTORY APPEAL by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN, 
                 from order entered 9/4/87, $5.00 filing fee and $100.00     
                 docketing fee paid. Mailed copies to:  A. Ferber, J.        
                 McCollum, Jr.  USCA/N    USCA NO. 87-5289 (yep)             
                 [Entry date 09/14/87] [Edit date 10/27/87]                  
                                                                             
10/2/87  --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson :  status    
                 hearing for 9:30 1/4/88  reporter P. Merana (cjp)           
                 [Entry date 10/05/87]                                       
                                                                             
10/2/87  11      ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson granting oral motion     
                 for leave to file amended compliant and allowing all        
                 parties leave to file supplemental memoranda and setting    
                 further  status hearing for 9:30 1/4/88  (N) (cjp)          
                 [Entry date 10/05/87]                                       

                 [Entry date 10/05/87]                                       
                                                                             
11/5/87  12      Transcript filed  for dates of 9/2/87  reporter M. Colchico 
                 (hls) [Entry date 11/06/87]                                 
                                                                             
11/10/87 13      CERTIFIED COPY OF ORDER filed in USCA 11/10/87 Granting     
                 appellant's motion to dismiss appeal pursuant to Rule       
                 42(b), FRAP  (USCA#87-5289) (ela) [Entry date 11/17/87]     
                                                                             
12/21/87 14      MEMORANDUM  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN in opposition to    
                 motion to dismiss the complaint as to OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL; 
                 attachment (hls)                                            
                                                                             
12/31/87 15      MOTION (second) by defendant OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL for       
                 summary judgment (kc) [Entry date 01/04/88]                 
                                                                             
1/4/88   --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson :  further   
                 status hearing and motions for 9:30 2/5/88  reporter        
                 P.Merana (hls) [Entry date 01/11/88]                        
                                                                             
2/10/88  16      STIPULATION AND ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  of      

2/10/88  16      STIPULATION AND ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  of      
                 counsel dismissing complaint with prejudice and without     
                 costs as to defendants Office of Independent Counsel        
                 Lawrence E. Walsh (N) (cjp) [Entry date 02/12/88]           
                                                                             
2/10/88  17      ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  granting motion to      
                 dismiss the complaint as to OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL [4-1]  (N) 
                 (cjp) [Entry date 02/12/88]                                 
                                                                             
2/11/88  --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson :  status    
                 hearing for 9:30 4/7/88  reporter P. Merana (hls)           
                 [Entry date 02/16/88]                                       
                                                                             
3/24/88  18      INTERROGATORIES filed  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to       
                 defendant CIA (hls) [Entry date 03/25/88]                   
                                                                             
3/24/88  19      INTERROGATORIES filed  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to       
                 defendant NATL. SEC. AGENCY (hls) [Entry date 03/25/88]     
                                                                             
                                                                             
                                                                             

                                                                             
Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 8                  
                                                                             
Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r     
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE
                                                                         JURY
3/24/88  20      REQUEST  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to defendant NATL.     
                 SEC. AGENCY for production of documents (hls)               
                 [Entry date 03/25/88]                                       
                                                                             
4/1/88   21      MOTION by defendant for protective order attachment (hls)   
                 [Entry date 04/04/88]                                       
                                                                             
4/5/88   22      REPLY  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to response to motion    
                 for protective order [21-1] by defendant; declaration (cjp) 
                                                                             
4/7/88   --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson : granted    
                 motion for protective order [21-1]; defendant to file       
                 dispositive motions within 30 days reporter P Merana (cjp)  
                 [Entry date 04/08/88]                                       
                                                                             

                                                                             
4/8/88   23      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson : granting motion for     
                 protective order [21-1] with all discovery stayed pending   
                 further order of the Court; defendants Department of the    
                 Air Force and National Security Agency shall file           
                 dispositive motions within 30 days; defendants FBI and      
                 National Security Council file "due diligence" affidavits   
                 within 30 days (N) (cjp) [Entry date 04/12/88]              
                                                                             
5/9/88   24      NOTICE OF FILING  by defendants of "due diligence"          
                 affidavit of FBI agent David R Lieberman (cjp)              
                 [Entry date 05/10/88]                                       
                                                                             
5/9/88   25      MOTION by defendant for partial summary judgment exhibits   
                 (8) (cjp) [Entry date 05/10/88]                             
                                                                             
5/20/88  26      MOTION by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to extend time to        
                 6/8/88 to file response to defts' motion for partial        
                 summary judgment (je) [Entry date 05/24/88]                 
                                                                             
5/26/88  27      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson : granting motion to      

5/26/88  27      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson : granting motion to      
                 extend time to 6/8/88 to file response to defts' motion for 
                 partial summary judgment [26-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN  (N) (mf) 
                 [Entry date 06/02/88]                                       
                                                                             
5/27/88  28      ENTERED IN ERROR    AMENDED COMPLAINT  by plaintiff PAUL    
                 GOLDSTEIN adding amending complaint [1-1] (mf)              
                 [Entry date 06/02/88] [Edit date 06/02/88]                  
                                                                             
6/7/88   29      MEMORANDUM  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN  in opposition to   
                 motion for partial summary judgment [25-1] by defendant;    
                 exhibits (5) (kc) [Entry date 06/13/88]                     
                                                                             
6/17/88  30      REPLY by defendantto response to motion for partial summary 
                 judgment [25-1] by defendant; exhibits (3) (je)             
                 [Entry date 06/23/88]                                       
                                                                             
6/17/88  31      TRANSCRIPT filed for dates of 2/11/88; pp. 1-10; reporter   
                 Phyllis Merana (je) [Entry date 06/23/88]                   
                                                                             
                                                                             

Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 9

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
7/21/88  32      MOTION by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to allow the taking of
                 discovery (gld) [Entry date 07/25/88]

7/21/88  33      MEMORANDUM  by defendants in opposition to motion to allow
                 the taking of discovery [32-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (ajr)
                 [Entry date 07/26/88]

7/25/88  34      MEMORANDUM  by defendant in opposition to motion to allow
                 the taking of discovery [32-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (kc)
                 [Entry date 07/27/88]

7/26/88  35      RESPONSE (FURTHER)  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN  in
                 opposition to motion for partial summary judgment [25-1] by
                 defendant, and in support of motion to allow the taking of
                 discovery [32-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (fiat) (cjp)
                 [Entry date 07/29/88]

7/28/88  36      MEMORANDUM AND ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson : granting
                 motion for partial summary judgment [25-1] by defendant,
                 denying motion to allow the taking of discovery [32-1] by
                 PAUL GOLDSTEIN dismissing as to defendant NATL. SEC.
                 COUNCIL, defendant CIA, defendant NATL. SEC. AGENCY,
                 defendant BATF, defendant DOE, defendant FEMA, defendant
                 DIA, defendant ARMY, defendant DON, defendant DEPT. OF AIR
                 FORCE, and setting a  status hearing for 9:30 9/28/88 as
                 to defendant FBI  (N) (cjp) [Entry date 08/03/88]

9/27/88  37      STATUS REPORT by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN; attachments (cjp)
                 [Entry date 09/29/88]

9/28/88  --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson :  status
                 hearing for 9:30 1/30/89  reporter P Merana (cjp)
                 [Entry date 10/02/88]

1/30/89  --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson : status
                 hearing set for 9:30 3/1/89 ;  reporter P. Merana (rew)

3/1/89   --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson ;deft to
                 file Vaughn Index and motion for summaryjudgment by 7/3/89
                 and Pltff to respond in 30 days. reporter P. Merana (rew)

3/1/89   38      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson directing deft to file
                 Vaughn Index and mo for summary judgment by 7/3/89 and
                 Pltff to respond by 8/3/89.  (N) (rew)

6/30/89  39      STIPULATION filed  and fiated  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson
                 that defts time to file Vaughn Index and motion for summary
                 judgment is extended to 7/17/89 and Pltffs response is due
                 on 8/17/89. (N) (rew)




Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 10

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
7/17/89  40      MOTION by defendant DEPT. OF AIR FORCE, defendant DON,
                 defendant U.S. DEPT. OF ARMY, defendant DIA, defendant
                 FEMA, defendant DOE, defendant BATF, defendant NSA,
                 defendant CIA, defendant NATL. SEC. COUNCIL, defendant FBI,
                 defendant OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL for summary judgment;
                 exhibits (31) (cjp)

8/17/89  41      STIPULATION by Judge Thomas P. Jackson : extending time to
                 9/1/89 for plaintiff to file his response to defendant's
                 Vaughn index and motion for summary judgment (N) (cjp)
                 [Entry date 08/18/89]

9/1/89   42      MOTION by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to extend time, for
                 discovery, or in the alternative for a supplemental
                 Vaughn Index; exhibits (4) (clv)

9/15/89  43      STIPULATION filed  and fiated  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson
                 that defts time is extended to 9-25-89 to file response to
                 pltffs motion for extension of time or for supplemental
                 Vaughn Index . (N) (rew) [Entry date 09/19/89]

9/25/89  44      MEMORANDUM  by defendant in support of motion to extend
                 time [42-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (mf) [Entry date 09/26/89]

10/16/89 45      REPLY  by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to opposition of FBI to
                 plaintiff's  motion for summary judgment [40-1];
                 attachments (2) (fiat) JACKSON, J. (cjp)
                 [Entry date 10/17/89]

2/21/90  46      SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL  for defendants substituting Marcia
                 Sowles for attorney Alan L. Ferber for OFFICE OF
                 INDEP.CNSL, FBI, NATL. SEC. COUNCIL, CIA, NSA, BATF, DOE
                 (ker) [Entry date 02/22/90]

5/22/90  47      NOTICE OF FILING by defendants of change of phone number
                 for counsel Marcia Sowles to 202-514-4960 (ker)
                 [Entry date 05/23/90]

9/21/90  48      MOTION by Bernard Fensterwald to withdraw as attorney for
                 PAUL GOLDSTEIN; Exhibit (1) (ker) [Entry date 09/26/90]
                 [Edit date 09/26/90]

10/4/90  49      RESPONSE by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN motion to withdraw as
                 attorney for PAUL GOLDSTEIN [48-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (cjp)
                 [Entry date 10/05/90]

10/18/90 50      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson : granting motion of
                 Bernard Fensterwald to withdraw as attorney for PAUL
                 GOLDSTEIN [48-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN and directing plaintiff
                 to notify the court within 15 days whether he intends to
                 retain new counsel. (N) (rew)




Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 11

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
5/21/91  51      SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL  for defendant OFFICE OF
                 INDEP.CNSL, defendant FBI, defendant NATL. SEC. COUNCIL,
                 defendant CIA, defendant NSA, defendant BATF, defendant
                 FEMA, defendant DIA, defendant U.S. DEPT. OF ARMY,
                 defendant DON, defendant DEPT. OF AIR FORCE substituting
                 for attorney Marcia Kay Sowles for DEPT. OF AIR FORCE,
                 attorney Marcia Kay Sowles for DON, attorney Marcia Kay
                 Sowles for U.S. DEPT. OF ARMY, attorney Marcia Kay Sowles
                 for DIA, attorney Marcia Kay Sowles for FEMA, attorney
                 Marcia Kay Sowles for DOE, attorney Marcia Kay Sowles for
                 BATF (cjp) [Entry date 05/23/91]

6/14/91  --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson : status
                 hearing set for 9:30 9/20/91 ;  reporter: P. Merana (rew)

8/9/91   52      TRANSCRIPT filed of status call  for date(s) of 6/14/91
                 reporter: Phyllis Merana (cjp) [Entry date 08/12/91]

9/20/91  --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson ,defendant
                 granted leave to file amenede motion for summary judgment
                 and Vaughn index within 90 days, plaintiff has l0 days to
                 reply and defendant has l0 days to respond. reporter: P.
                 Merana (rew)

9/23/91  53      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  :  defendant's amended
                 motion for summary judgement due 12/19/91 ; plaintiff's
                 response to motion for summary judgement due 1/21/92;
                 defendant's reply motion for summary judgement due 1/31/92 ;
                  plaintiff's surreply to motion due 2/10/92 ; (N) (cjp)
                 [Entry date 09/24/91]

12/19/91 54      MOTION by defendants for summary judgment; attachments (clv)
                 [Entry date 12/20/91]

12/20/91 55      ATTORNEY APPEARANCE  for defendant DEPT. OF AIR FORCE,
                 defendant DON, defendant U.S. DEPT. OF ARMY, defendant DIA,
                 defendant FEMA, defendant DOE, defendant BATF, defendant
                 NSA, defendant CIA, defendant NATL. SEC. COUNCIL, defendant
                 FBI, defendant OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL by Elizabeth Ann Pugh
                 (cjp) [Entry date 12/23/91]

1/13/92  56      MOTION filed by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN  to modify the
                 schedule to extend the due dates for responses to
                 defendant's amended summary judgment motion (cjp)
                 [Entry date 01/15/92]

1/16/92  57      RESPONSE by defendant FBI motion to modify the schedule to
                 extend the due dates for responses to defendant's amended
                 summary judgment motion [56-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN;
                 attachments (kmk) [Entry date 01/17/92]




Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 12

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
1/28/92  58      REPLY  by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to motion to modify
                 the schedule to extend the due dates for responses to
                 defendant's amended summary judgment motion [56-1] by PAUL
                 GOLDSTEIN (cjp) [Entry date 01/29/92]

2/10/92  59      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : granting motion  to
                 modify the schedule to extend the due dates for responses
                 to defendant's amended summary judgment motion [56-1] by
                 PAUL GOLDSTEIN  plaintiff's response to motion for summary
                 judgement due 2/27/92 and defendant's reply motion for
                 summary judgement due 3/9/92 ; plaintiff's surreply due
                 3/19/92 ;  (N) (cjp) [Entry date 02/11/92]

3/2/92   60      CROSS MOTIONS by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN for summary
                 judgment; attachments and exhibits (kmk)
                 [Entry date 03/03/92]

3/2/92   61      MOTION filed by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to compel a
                 further search (kmk) [Entry date 03/03/92]

3/9/92   62      MOTION filed by defendants to extend time to 4/8/92 to
                 respond to plaintiff's opposition to defendant FBI's
                 amended motion for summary judgment and plaintiff's cross
                 motion for summary judgment and motion to compel a further
                 search (cjp) [Entry date 03/10/92]

3/12/92  63      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : granting motion to
                 extend time to 4/8/92 to respond to plaintiff's opposition
                 to defendant FBI's amended motion for summary judgment and
                 plaintiff's cross motion for summary judgment and motion to
                 compel a further search [62-1] by defendant response to
                 motion for summary judgement due 4/8/92  (N) (cjp)
                 [Entry date 03/13/92]

4/8/92   64      REPLY  by defendant FBI to plaintiff's opposition to
                 amended to motion for summary judgment [40-1] by defendants;
                  declarations (2); attachments (cjp) [Entry date 04/13/92]

4/8/92   65      RESPONSE  by defendant FBI  in opposition to cross motion
                 for summary judgment [60-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (cjp)
                 [Entry date 04/13/92]

4/15/92  66      NOTICE OF FILING by defendant FBI of ex parte, in camera
                 for submission (cjp) [Entry date 04/16/92]

4/22/92  67      MOTION (unopposed) filed by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to
                 extend time to 4/27/92 to file his response to defendant's
                 response to plaintiff's cross motion for summary judgment
                 (cjp) [Entry date 04/23/92]

4/23/92  68      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : granting motion to
                 extend time to 4/27/92 to file his response to defendant's
                 response to plaintiff's cross motion for summary judgment
                 [67-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN brief due 4/27/92 ;  (N) (cjp)



Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 13

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
                 [Entry date 04/24/92]

4/28/92  69      REPLY by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to defendant FBI'S
                 opposition to cross motion for summary judgment [60-1] by
                 PAUL GOLDSTEIN; attachments (3) (kmk) [Entry date 04/30/92]

4/29/92  70      RESPONSE (OPPOSITIONS) by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to
                 notice of ex parte in camera submission [66-1] by FBI;
                 attachments (cjp) [Entry date 04/30/92]

5/7/92   71      MOTION (unopposed) filed by defendant to extend time to
                 5/11/92 to respond to plaintiff's opposition to
                 defendant's notice of ex parte, in camera submission (kmk)

5/11/92  72      REPLY by defendant FBI to plaintiff's opposition to notice
                 of ex parte, in camera declaration for submission [66-1] by
                 FBI (cjp) [Entry date 05/12/92]

5/18/92  73      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : granting motion to
                 extend time to 5/11/92 to respond to plaintiff's opposition
                 to defendant's notice of ex parte, in camera submission
                 [71-1] by defendant; nunc pro tunc  (N) (cjp)
                 [Entry date 05/19/92]

6/22/92  74      MEMORANDUM by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN RE:  request to
                 conduct an in camera inspection of 3/31/88 FBI letter to
                 the Joint Chief of Staff; exhibits (19) (cjp)
                 [Entry date 06/23/92]

7/22/92  75      RESPONSE (OPPOSITIONS) by defendant FBI to supplemental
                 reply [74-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (kmk) [Entry date 07/23/92]

8/11/92  76      REPLY by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to defendant FBI's
                 response to supplemental reply [74-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN
                  (fiat) Jackson, J. (kmk) [Entry date 08/12/92]

2/16/93  77      NOTICE OF FILING by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN copies of
                 three documents released to another FOIA requestor by the
                 Dept. of Defense (kmk) [Entry date 02/17/93]

2/16/93  78      MOTION filed by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN for further
                 search of other related documents (kmk)
                 [Entry date 02/17/93]

2/25/93  79      ATTORNEY APPEARANCE  for defendant FBI by Patricia Arzuaga
                 (clv) [Entry date 02/26/93]

2/25/93  80      MOTION filed by defendant FBI to extend time to 3/11/93 to
                 file a responsive pleading to plaintiff's notice of filing
                 and motion for further search (clv) [Entry date 02/26/93]




Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 14

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
2/26/93  81      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : granting motion to
                 extend time to 3/11/93 to file a responsive pleading to
                 plaintiff's notice of filing and motion for further search
                 [80-1] by FBI  (N) (rew) [Entry date 03/01/93]

3/12/93  82      RESPONSE (OPPOSITIONS) by defendant FBI to copies of three
                 documents relating to another FOIA request by the
                 Department of Defense [77-1] and Request for further search
                 by PAUL GOLDSTEIN; declaration (1) (cjp)
                 [Entry date 03/15/93]

3/29/93  83      MOTION filed by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN for leave to
                 file reply to defendant's opposition out of time EXHIBIT
                 (reply) (cjp) [Entry date 03/30/93]

4/1/93   84      ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : granting motion for
                 leave to file reply to defendant's opposition out of time
                 [83-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN  (N) (cjp) [Entry date 04/02/93]

4/1/93   85      REPLY  by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to defendant's
                 opposition to plaintiff's notice of filing and motion for
                 further search of other related documents [78-1] by PAUL
                 GOLDSTEIN (cjp) [Entry date 04/02/93]

6/10/93  86      NOTICE OF FILING by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN of recent
                 Supreme Court decison; attachment. (pao)
                 [Entry date 06/11/93]

6/10/93  87      SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM to motion to compel a further
                 search [61-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN and cross motion for
                 summary judgment [60-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN. (pao)
                 [Entry date 06/11/93]

6/18/93  88      ORDER by Judge Thomas P. Jackson: denying motion for
                 further search of other related documents [78-1] by PAUL
                 GOLDSTEIN  (N) (pob)

6/21/93  89      MOTION (unopposed) filed by defendant to extend time to
                 10/20/93 to respond to plaintiff's notice of filing and
                 supplemental memorandum in support of plaintiff's
                 cross-motion for summary judgment and motion to compel a
                 further search (kmk) [Entry date 06/22/93]

6/29/93  90      ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : denying motion as
                 moot to extend time to 10/20/93 to respond to plaintiff's
                 notice of filing and supplemental memorandum in support of
                 plaintiff's cross-motion for summary judgment and motion to
                 compel a further search [89-1] by defendants  (N) (rew)

7/12/93  91      MOTION filed by plaintiff(s) PAUL GOLDSTEIN to clarify
                 Court's recent order filed 06/29/93 (kmk)
                 [Entry date 07/13/93]




Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 15

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
7/20/93  92      RESPONSE by defendant FBI to motion to clarify Court's
                 recent order filed 06/29/93 [91-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN (pob)
                 [Entry date 07/21/93]

7/21/93  93      ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  considering motion to
                 clarify Court's recent order filed 06/29/93 [91-1] by PAUL
                 GOLDSTEIN the Orders of 6/18/93 and 6/29/93 are vacated,
                 denying plaintiffs motion for further search,granting
                 defendants unopposed motion for extension of time filed
                 6/21/93,and extending defendants time to l0/20/93 to
                 respond to plaintiffs supplemental memorandum in support of
                 plaintiffs cross-motion for summary judgment and in support
                 of plaintiffs motion to compel a further search. (N) (rew)
                 [Entry date 07/23/93]

10/20/93 94      NOTICE OF FILING by defendant FBI; First Declaration of
                 Michael D. Turner; Exhibit (1) (ew) [Entry date 10/21/93]

9/27/95  --      SCHEDULING NOTICE: status hearing set for 9:30 11/1/95 ;
                 before Judge Thomas P. Jackson . (rew)

11/27/95 --      STATUS HEARING before Judge Thomas P. Jackson:  in camera
                 review of 96 documents in the courtroom on 1/31/96 at 10:00
                 a.m. and to continue to 2/2/96. Reporter: Phyllis Merana
                 (kmk)

11/27/95 95      ATTORNEY APPEARANCE  for defendant FBI by Karen Richardson.
                 (kmk) [Entry date 11/29/95]

12/18/95 96      STATUS REPORT by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN.  Report to the
                 Court concerning the IN CAMERA REVIEW.  Plaintiff submits
                 his list of contested documents which are to be reviewed by
                 the Court IN CAMERA.; exhibits (1) (dam)
                 [Entry date 12/19/95]

1/11/96  97      NOTICE OF FILING by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN, filing a slip
                 opinion in Lesar v. CIA., cv no. 93-2598.; attachments (1)
                 (dam) [Entry date 01/16/96]

1/31/96  --      STATUS HEARING before Judge Thomas P. Jackson:   case
                 referral to Special Master for review of non B1 documents;
                 Defendants' motion for summary judgment; granted in
                 reference to B1 documents. Reporter:  Phyllis Merana (kmk)

1/31/96  98      ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson ;granting in part
                 defendant's motion for summary judgment and denying in part
                 plantiff's motion for summary judgment with respect to 5
                 USC 552(b)(1) exemptions; and referring remaining disputed
                 exemptions to a Special Master; and staying all other
                 proceedings pending receipt of the report of the Special
                 Master and further order of this court. (N) (rew)
                 [Entry date 02/01/96]




Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 16

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
2/23/96  99      ORDER of reference to Special Master  by Judge Thomas P.
                 Jackson, and appointing Curtis E. von Kann as Special
                 Master, directing Special Master to make an in camera
                 examination of certain documents and report to the Court by
                 4-30-96, and with other instructions to the Special Master
                 and on compensation. (N) (rew) [Entry date 02/26/96]

3/18/96  100     TRANSCRIPT of proceedings before Thomas P. Jackson filed
                 for date(s) of 01/31/96.   Reporter: Phyllis Merana. (kmk)
                 [Entry date 03/19/96]

3/22/96  --      SCHEDULING NOTICE: status hearing set for 9:30 4/2/96 ;
                 before Judge Thomas P. Jackson . (rew)

4/1/96   101     RESPONSE by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to order [99-1];
                 attachments (2) (dam) [Entry date 04/02/96]

4/1/96   102     MOTION filed by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN to vacate Order
                 of 2/23/96 (dam) [Entry date 04/02/96]

4/2/96   --      STATUS HEARING  before Judge Thomas P. Jackson ; a Special
                 Master will not be appointed. Reporter: P. Merana (rew)

4/2/96   103     ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson ,vacating order of
                 2-23-96 referring case to a special master. (N) (rew)
                 [Entry date 04/04/96]

4/11/96  104     MOTION filed by defendants to extend time to 4/25/96 to
                 filoe a response to plaintiff's reply to the Court's
                 2/23/96 Order (dam) [Entry date 04/12/96]

4/12/96  105     ORDER   by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : granting motion to
                 extend time to 4/25/96 to filoe a response to plaintiff's
                 reply to the Court's 2/23/96 Order [104-1] by defendants
                 (N) (rew) [Entry date 04/15/96]

4/25/96  106     RESPONSE by defendant FBI to plaintiff's response to the
                 Court's order of 2/23/96 [101-1] by PAUL GOLDSTEIN;
                 exhibits (5) (dam) [Entry date 04/26/96]

9/3/96   --      SCHEDULING NOTICE: status hearing set for 9:30 11/1/96 ;
                 before Judge Thomas P. Jackson . (rew)

5/15/97  107     ORDER  by Judge Thomas P. Jackson  : referring for in
                 camera inspection of documents and findings of fact and
                 recommend the conclusions of law to Magistrate Judge  (N)
                 (pao)

5/15/97  --      CASE REFERRED   to Mag. Judge Patrick J. Attridge for
                 report and recommendation (mmh) [Entry date 05/16/97]

5/21/97  --      SCHEDULING NOTICE: status hearing set for 10:30 6/24/97 ;
                 before Mag. Judge Patrick J. Attridge . (pao)




Docket as of December 15, 1997 7:01 pm               Page 17

Proceedings include all events.                                   MAGr&r
1:87cv2028    GOLDSTEIN v. OFFICE OF INDEP.CNSL, et al                   TYPE I
                                                                         JURY
5/22/97  --      SCHEDULING NOTICE: status hearing reset to 2:00 6/24/97
                 before Mag. Judge Patrick J. Attridge . (pao)

6/24/97  108     STATUS REPORT by plaintiff PAUL GOLDSTEIN, as of June 24,
                 1997; exhibit (1). (tth) [Entry date 06/25/97]

6/24/97  --      STATUS HEARING  before Mag. Judge Patrick J. Attridge:
                 defendant to produce documents by 7/1/97. Reporter: Tape AS
                 32-97; Lines 4710-5248 (pao) [Entry date 06/25/97]

7/1/97   109     NOTICE OF FILING by defendant FBI of the declaration of
                 Bobbie S. Olivarri; declaration (1); attachments (3) (blj)
                 [Entry date 07/03/97]

[END OF DOCKET: 1:87cv2028]




X---------------------------------------------------------------------------X
